The Church of England has threatened to sue Sony after the Japanese company used Manchester Cathedral as the backdrop to the gunfight in the PlayStation 3 game Resistance:The Fall of Man. And they could have a case.
“
Isnt that a bit bizzarre? I mean if outside-buildings are considered protected under the law in the future, there will be no movies, no games and not even any private photos, since you have to pay for it.
Today you are free to shoot pictures outside a building but according to the business.timesonline article”the legal situation changes radically, once a game enters the doors of a location.
The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 contains the so-called “2D to 3D rule”. Designed to prevent architects’ blue prints being bootlegged by builders who could use them to build replica buildings it could also stop a games developer creating a fictional representation of a real site.
That means that EA Games, the biggest games developer, which features the new Wembley Stadium in its FIFA series of football games, has had to receive permission from the Football Association to do so.
“If a computer game developer is copying a landmark there generally isn’t a problem,” Mr Frederikse said. “But if a developer were to use details from inside a new building they will run into real trouble if they don’t have permission.”
In general a “2D to 3D” case can only be made if a copyright holder is still alive or has died in the past 70 years
– a potential problem for the Church of England as Manchester Cathedral’s archives stem back as far as 1361 – though it was extensively rebuilt after the Second World War. “
So why do they have a case, you ask?
Well the Church argue that it owns the copyright to the photos that Sony is thought to have used to recreate Manchester Cathedral.
The Church could follow action under libel or trade libel laws. “The Church is by no means home on this, but if it could prove it has been sullied in the eyes of worshippers who believe it has endorsed or authorised this game.”
Let’s hope that there will be some sort of reason in all this and all hope that the church has better things to do than taking Sony to court becourse of this.
Source:business.timesonline
resistance-fall-of-ma, manchesiter-choir, games, lawyer